The Bottom Line
Pros
- Appealing performances and engaging characters
- Sharp dialogue a cut above the typical teen show
- Great sense of energy and fun
Cons
- Potentially difficult to expand movie's premise into a long-running series
- Offers characters and situations familiar from plenty of teen shows
- Mostly plays things safe
Description
- Pilot airs July 7, 2009, at 8 p.m. EST on ABC Family
- Stars Lindsey Shaw, Meaghan Martin, Larry Miller, Ethan Peck, Nicholas Braun and Dana Davis
- Developed by Carter Covington, based on the movie written by Kirsten Smith and Karen McCullah Lutz
Guide Review - '10 Things I Hate About You' Pilot
The premise here is basically the same: The teenage Stratford sisters Kat (Lindsey Shaw) and Bianca (Meaghan Martin) are polar opposites, with Kat a nonconforming feminist rebel and Bianca a peppy cheerleader wannabe. They head to a new school, where Kat meets a brooding biker and Bianca is pursued by a kind-hearted dork, but their dad (Larry Miller, returning from the movie, and funny as ever) has laid down a rule for the sisters: Bianca isn’t allowed to date until the antisocial Kat does as well.
The pilot sets up the premise and the basic relationships, and pretty much amounts to the same story beats from the movie’s first half-hour. That’s not really a problem: There are enough changes and updates (references to Facebook, etc.) for it to feel fresh, and the recycled elements worked the first time for a reason. Despite their differences, Kat and Bianca are both easy to identify with and root for, and their respective love interests show potential. Even the requisite snotty queen bee of the school has a nice sassy edge. If you appreciate well-written teen entertainment like Clueless, Popular or the original 10 Things I Hate About You, then you’ll find a lot here to like—no matter what your age or gender.


