The Bottom Line
Pros
- Likable, amusing new characters and modified setting with definite potential
- A welcome expanded role for Season 8’s recurring player Eliza Coupe
- The same goofy charm that has made the series so long-beloved
Cons
- A little too overreliant on tired fantasy sequences
- Older characters sometimes seem forced into the new setting
- John C. McGinley’s Dr. Cox back to being one-dimensional
Description
- First two episodes air December 1, 2009, at 9 and 9:30 p.m. EST on ABC
- Stars Zach Braff, Donald Faison, John C. McGinley, Eliza Coupe, Kerry Bishe, Michael Mosley, Dave Franco
- Created by Bill Lawrence
Guide Review - 'Scrubs' Season 9 Premiere Episodes
While it’s nice to see both J.D. and Turk still around (J.D. splits his customary narration with the new lead character, med student Lucy Bennett, played by Kerry Bishe), it also makes it a little tough to move on and focus on the new cast members, who at least come off as entertaining and worth watching. Less welcome is Dr. Cox, whose I-hate-everyone shtick was already getting mighty old, and whose more humanizing characteristics are not on display, at least in these episodes. And the overly dopey fantasy sequences, which became far too prevalent in recent seasons, could definitely be toned down.
Still, the best thing about these episodes is that they demonstrate potential for a show about the new (and new-ish) characters. Lucy is as appealing an everywoman med student as J.D. was an appealing everyman doctor; Michael Mosley’s Drew, an older student returning to med school after flaming out once, is a new character type for the show to explore; and Eliza Coupe really steps up as the abrasive but level-headed Denise, in a role expanded from her periodic appearances in Season 8. Dave Franco’s self-important Cole is so far a little one-note, but even so, I’m interested in watching a show about these characters. At this point, the show is only about halfway really about them, but it’s enough to make it worth keeping an eye on.
Disclosure: A review screener was provided by the network. For more information, please see our Ethics Policy.


